Almost un-noticed in the ‘gold rush’ of self-publishing and the obstinacy of traditional publishing to cling on to the old ways has been the fact that writers really need to re-evaluate what it means to have a career as an author.
The traditional route was:
Write a book. Get an agent. Agent sells to editor. Editor promotes in-house. Sales reps place books in stores. Stores sell books to readers. Hope for an explosion out of the gate with hitting a bestseller list (only possible, though, if enough books have been placed, which rarely happens for new authors). Wait six months on numbers. Up or out. 90% out.
In essence, you had to go to bat and hit a home run. There was also a place for the midlist author to swing away hitting singles and doubles for years before finally getting that opportunity to hit that home run.
That’s all changing. First, the midlist is becoming extinct as retail outlets disappear. Second, the bestseller lists are crowded with the usual names as publisher focus on known, brand name authors, who make 90% of their money.
So now we have a rush, a gold rush as the Washington Post called it, or simply a pile of gold known as backlist, according to Forbes where I was quoted. While the latter has some validity, the former is very misleading if you want a career as an author, which I define as making a living off of your writing.
The Amanda Hockings model is, in essence, much like the JK Rowling model. An aberration that you shouldn’t waste your time studying, other than for the smart lessons she’s passed on about things she did to help sell books.
What I’m seeing is that 95% of those indie publishing want instant validation and gratification. That’s no different than the percentages when print on demand first became available. In 2006 there were 1.2 million titles available. And 950,000 of those titles sold less than 99 copies. The percentages are little different now with eBooks.
Almost all the talk in indie publishing is about promotion and sales, when it really should be more about craft and writing. Becoming a better writer is the #1 way to improve sales.
Instead of a gold rush, consider it a marathon. Instead of rushing books out and checking your Kindle sales every day, hoping to see money pouring in, focus on the writing. The ‘long tail’ is the key to success as an indie author and that is why there is gold in backlist. Right now, my Atlantis series is our bread and butter, while my newly uploaded Area 51 series is surging upward as more titles become available.
I’ve reached and passed the point where I can be self-sustaining financially, simply based on my backlist. Thus, writing forward, projecting out successful series, is icing on the cake. My first original book straight to eBook, Chasing The Ghost, has been sitting in the top 10 Men’s Adventure now for two months. For a new writer, with no backlist, you have to think in terms of many books, not just one or two. Don’t worry about sales now. Worry about writing better books. Building your readership, slowly but surely. Establishing a line of books that will have your readers anticipating the next one coming out. Perhaps even write shorter books, 50-60 thousand words, rather than the usual 80-100 thousand. Keep building community via social media.
Those who are who are in this for the long haul, who are willing to learn in order to become better writers, who have the focus on their strategic goal as I teach in Warrior Writer, will be the ones who will succeed.
As part of rethinking things, next month we’ll be teaching Marketing and the Writer on-line at Write It Forward.














Great perspective Bob. Thanks for keeping my lens wiped clear. It gets hard to keep my head down and write when every direction is bombarding me with the newest and shiniest way to get published.
For today, I shall write…and tomorrow…and the next day. I’ve learned to redefine what success looks like for me and attach joy to the process of crafting the best book I possibly can, instead of the “someday” joy of a published book (or, a gold vein of backlist) though that, and being financially supported by my books, is still the long-term goal.
Jen
I’m so glad to hear someone else say this. You’re right. All I hear is promotion/sales/yada yada. I rarely hear ANYONE talk about the most important things involved in writing: craft.
If you wish to be a writer, you have to think of it as a career (as opposed to a job where you just do what people tell you to do). Having a career means constantly working to make your output better. Continual improvement.
Thanks!
As always, Bob, you give great advice. I find the whole promo situation these days to be so exhausting, not to mention taking a huge toll on craft and creativity. It’s a trap we all fall into, myself included, and it’s good to get a reminder of what really matters to readers – the book.
So many of the new author ebooks I have read lately contain outstanding grammar and context errors. The rush to publish and get on the e-train has opened the door to criticism of the quality of ALL direct to ebooks. Bob offers some down to earth help for any writer hoping to be successful in this new and exciting venue. There are great ideas out there and wonderful new authors to be heard. Don’t let simple errors mar the quality of your hard work. Follow the advice of those who are there…They are not you competition…Embrace them as mentors.
It is heartening to hear that if I keep plugging away, writing quality stories, it may pay off somewhere down the road.
Two ideas.
Writing a bestseller implies you have a household name. The person who can do this won’t have to worry about getting sales nor publishing.
To get a household name you have to write a book people will talk about. This ensures you have a fan base who will buy anything you write.
I’m also hearing complaints about mistakes — grammatical and skill-wise — in e-books as they are easy to get to market, as it were. But, the past few years, I’ve been finding drastic mistakes in well-known authors’ books from major publishers. Seems everyone needs to work on several skills — from the unknowns to the major players.
Again, thanks, Bob, for hitting the nail on the head once again!
Interesting. I had this very conversation this morning at brunch with a writing friend, who’s original background ironically is in marketing. At least you put it a little nicer and you didn’t whack the back of my head, Bob.
Great post. Everything you said can be characterized with one word: professionalism.
Either way, traditional or indie or a combination of both, if one is professional about his work in all aspects (producing, editing, publishing, marketing, promoting), no matter the way, he/she will succeed at some point, sooner or later.
If one is not professional, like rushing out publishing something without review, editing, platform etc. then he/she will fail, sooner rather than later.
Common sense and life lesson. Professionalism should be applied in any job to succeed.
Thank you for the interesting post
Thanks for the feedback. Throughout my 20 years in publishing, I always have to remember craft comes first. Nowadays it’s really easy to get caught up in marketing.
Pingback: Reviews, Weight Loss, and Homemade Beauty Potions | Marta Daniels
hear! hear!
I self-published a novella last year, but since then, I have learned a lot more about writing and decided to revise my book and relaunch it in April. I’m much happier with it as I believe it is now a better story. My slim sales are encouraging, but my goal is to build a fanbase and make a living as an author.
While I work hard at building my brand, I remind myself regularly that my writing will be the biggest component of that brand. So I continue to learn about writing. I am using 90 Days To Your Novel by Sarah Domet to write another story. I’m enjoying the challenge of thinking about story writing in a structured manner – something which I resisted for years. Oddly and happily, I find the structure to be liberating.
As you pointed out, there’s so much talk about selling and so little about improving one’s craft that it is easy to lose sight of what really matters: the quality of the writing and, I suppose, the quality of the writer. Thank you for writing this post.
Great article! Thanks for this. Long haul is the way to go. No matter what.
Pingback: Rethinking an Author’s Career Path | indiopress
Great post Bob – it’s hard to see the wood for the trees sometimes.I think Irene hit the nail on the head there: it’s all about professionalism. And Patricia – that’s also a good move: I would love to have the money to get my work edited professionally. Until I have that cash, I have to rely on my own skills and those of my first readers and critique group. It’s a fine balance between writing and marketing, but I believe ultimately, if you do your best at writing, the sales will catch up, and when that happens (or before, should my boss decide a raise is a good idea), I fully intend to revise what’s already published in order to ensure that it’s the best version of my work for my readers.
Bob, thanks for this incredibly balanced and motivating post. I’ve focused on my craft and, many times, felt like my novels were lost in the ePub and Indie anarchy long before I got them revised. That is so self defeating and wrong-headed: I bought into the hype and it fueled my fear that I’d never be published. I’ve stopped doing that; been following a steady-as-she-blows course for two years now, getting my novels finished and polished, building my platform, and figuring out where I can reasonably fit in as I grow and as my writing matures. As always, thanks for a great post.
“Don’t worry about sales now. Worry about writing better books.”
Guess I’m doing something right after all. I don’t even look at my Kindle (etc) sales. Don’t tweet book BS, or clog up FB with links, or spam the world with announcements, or any of that “promo” stuff. I’ve got 2 YAs ‘out there’ but for now I’m just concentrating on the writing, editing, & polishing. Maybe later (3 books from now?) I’ll think about the marketing & sales.
Hi Bob,
Thanks for the post. Been lurking for a bit, figured I’d chime in with a somewhat related question. You mention we should think about writing shorter novels to take advantage of the new situation. What do you think about the serialized novel of old? Do you see a potential comeback for this format? (Hoping you do, as that’s the direction I’m heading.)
A. J. Abbiati
Bob’s article is very informative and to the point. Quality rather than quanity at this point in my literary career seems to make sense. Also Dave Elbright makes a good point when he mentions the world, of which I term, “spam clog.” Sure, spending endless hours on facebook, marketing to an captive crowd with twaddle and a constant barrage of “marketing genius” to the choir is not the best practice to honing one’s craft. My work should stand on its own without the tiresome and bothersome “In your Face” announcements, blogs or incessant blurbs, this waste of time seems to do more harm than good. Allowing the age old adage, “The best advertising is word of mouth” seems to be the best advice I ever recieved. However another adage takes hold, “Let time take time.” But that requires patience, something that is not practiced in a world of instant gradification. Oh and another thing, the statement, “Any publicity is good publicity” does not particularly work in the world of literary craft. Let your customers give you the positive feedback and publicity you warrant by your hard work, “Don’t serve the public with drast, let the public serve you! They will with time and you will perservere with hard work and discipline.
Bob’s comments are a hard truth. Even though, being an author, I would like to shout to the treetops and announce to the waiting world of my literary gem by a constant barrage of marketing twaddle and drast that seems to preach to the same old choir has proved to be a waste of time. The age old adage of letting the work stand on its own by word of mouth advertising, good quality and literary integrity has its benefits as far as positive sales. However, that has an unfortuante drawback, PATIENCE. Letting time be time is not in todays phraseology where instant gratification is the rule of the day. Concentrate on quality, concentrate on the honest reconigtion of your public and don’t fall into the trap of “Any publicity is good publicity.” I fell into that abyss and it is not an easy pill to swallow. Let your public serve you, don’t serve your public with your greatness!
The serialized novel doesn’t work. It’s a great idea and we thought it would really work, so we released Chasing the Ghost in seven “episodes”. Few went for it. People want the entire thing for $2.99 rather than pieces for .99. I almost released Duty, Honor, Country in three parts since it’s huge– 175,000 words. But decided against that as the book had all the elements of narrative structure. We did make the price a bit higher, $4.99.
I’ve been going through one of my earlier books, cleaning it up for upload and cringing at some of my early writing. Argh. And this was a book that sold 100,000 copies. I tried to clean up some of it, but I am such a different writer now than even two years ago.
Hmmm….well, I guess for this go-around I’ll take what I can get prior to the novel release, then replace the single episodes with the full novel a few months after releasing it. Doubt I’ll do it this way again, as I’m experiencing the same thing. I suppose we’re fighting the ‘instant gratification’ typical of our age.
Great post Bob.
I just blog about “Luck” being a huge factor in the sale of any book “e” or otherwise…The best way to improve that luck? Write great books and the sale should follow.
Vin
I haven’t been around long, but I have yet to be steered wrong by anything Warrior Writer. Thank you for sharing your experience.
Great advice and a good reminder, too. I *have* to stop checking my sales. Need to put out more books. And I like the idea of shorter books. The one I just finished outlining I plan on running about 60k. I think shorter books lend themselves well to the e-format. Plus, they make for quick, fun reads–which is exactly what I’m going for.
It always comes down to improving our craft and writing better books. Once we’ve published, no matter the method, its easy to get caught up in the marketing and promotion. Actually, it’s easy to get caught up in it before we publish because in this day and age, in order to get ahead, you have to be ahead of the game. Agents and Publishers want to see that you have a platform and are already “out there” promoting yourself.
Both parts of the business are essential for success. It takes a lot of patience and hard work, but the pay off is well worth it. I have learned more these past two years than I have since I began writing. We have to slow the pace down just a little. It’s not how fast you come out of the gate, though its nice to see sales right off the bat, but more importantly continuing to grow and develop and keep it up without burning yourself out.
I so love this advice. It’s affirmation because this is exactly what I decided to do a couple of months ago.
Thanks for so freely giving your knowledge as a successful author. I really appreciate it.
Write well and incessantly, promote intelligently and non-stop. Then repeat often. Good advice, Bob.
Larry
Insightful post, think you are hitting it right on the head Bob.
Excellent perspective Bob and great feedback in the comments. It is very easy to get caught up in the social media and marketing aspect of things. Craft should and always need to come first. I’m working on setting myself scheduled times on the Internet as a way to limit the nagging need to Tweet or check email. I need to keep my focus on the craft and work on my “marathon” training rather than trying to sprint my way to my goals.
Great post and if anyone reading this hasn’t purchased a copy of Bob’s ‘Warrior Writer’ go buy it now!
Happy writing and marathon training to all!
Natalie
Thanks for the reminder, Bob! Focus on writing and worry about marketing less.
Bob,
Thanks for some more learning. It’s been a rip-roaring 2011 so far with you, Jenni and Kristen. WDW has yet to steer me wrong!
Pingback: The End is Near (and we deserve it). . . . School Understaffed, but wants iPads for Kindergarteners « Author Piper Bayard
Pingback: A Storm on the Horizon « Rob Holts Writer Unextraordinaire
Great post! I’ve been busy getting my first two books ready to go as back to back releases (and that darn day job) that I haven’t had time for new writing – BUT – I have sent myself up with a production schedule to keep myself on track. And yes I plan on making my works shorter because I tend to write short and plan to sell at a lower price point.
Pingback: Learning Television Production | Learn TV Production
Pingback: Finds on the Feed and, oh yeah, this… | Elen Grey's Blog